I figured we should learn from the experience of the military data classification, a system that deals with very sensitive data in a different way. (Note that we are already ahead of the military in that we have a global vocabulary, take a look at the mapping mess that is military data classification). In the case of the military classifications they use relative “harm to the country” as their measure. Yes this is different than healthcare information, but I think we can see that “harm to the patient” is what we have been discussing. Especially if we look at ‘harm’ in a broad sense that includes
- reputation damage,
- emotional damage,
- family relationship damage,
- financial damage, and
- physical damage (safety).
I think it is very legitimate to include in our definitions contemporary examples from well-known countries policies. Such as in the USA with HIPAA vs 42 CFR Part 2.
So, here is a potential draft using the existing codes, just new definitions
- U – Unrestricted – No specific patient is identified and thus there is no patient harm risk
- L – Low – Data has been de-identified and there are mitigating circumstances that prevent re-identification such that there is remote harm risk to the patient if the data were exposed. The data however still requires protection from exposure outside intended use.
- M – Moderate – Data are identifiable but consists of modest clinical information that would present moderate harm risk to the patient if the data were exposed. Example include an emergency-data-set made up of non-sensitive problems, allergies, and medications.
- N – Normal – Data are identifiable and of typical health information that would present typical harm risk to the patient if the data are exposed. This code is used for the majority of clinical information. Examples include what HIPAA identifies as Protected Health Information.
- R – Restricted – Data are identifiable and of an especially sensitive nature that would present a high risk to the patient if the data are exposed. Examples include the data topics identified in USA 42 CFR Part 2 – “CONFIDENTIALITY OF ALCOHOL AND DRUG ABUSE PATIENT RECORDS”.
- V – Very Restricted – Data are identifiable and of extreme sensitive nature that would present a very high risk to the patient if the data are exposed. Data in classified Very Restrictive should be kept in the highest confidence.